Share this article: Bookmark and Share

Consumer Law Blog

When not to cry "Unfair Dismissal"

by Elliot 16 December 2009

There has been a spate of unfair dismissal cases in the news recently brought about by hard-done-by ex-employees. Most of these cases are warranted but as the recession rumbles on, and people get more and more desperate to cling on to an income, tribunals are seeing an increase in blinkered and impossibly optimistic claims.

For example, Alistair Sim was fired from his advertising job after being convicted of beating up his girlfriend. You'd think that he'd put his hands up and accept that committing a serious crime is probably a valid sackable offence. But no, he cried unfair dismissal and went to employment tribunal where perhaps unsurprisingly it was unanimously ruled that he was NOT unfairly dismissed.

Another hopeless case was that of Anthony Stewart, an estate agent from Bournemouth, who claimed he was unfairly dismissed after he watched hundreds of hours of porn on his office computer. He claimed that the racy material distracted him from his online poker addiction. Needless to say, the tribunal ruled against him.

Lastly, Phillippa Heath-Philpotts from London lost her unfair dismissal case after she was sacked for punching a colleague during a Christmas party. Her job? A teacher whose job involved helping pupils with aggression.

If there is one positive from all these outlandish claims it shows that the employment tribunal system in this country is pretty accommodating. Employees may not win every time but at least they are given the chance to appeal against their dismissals in the first place.

To find out more about unfair dismissal, and what to do if you have been unfairly dismissed then click here to go to our free unfair dismissal guide.

Claims Financial

Comments (1)

Post a comment

  • employer10/06/1109:08

    the negative side of this is from an employers point of view thousands are spent defending these nonsense claims that they cant afford and could put the business under.

  • Reclaim Card Charges

    Claim Back £100's in Unfair Credit Card Charges TODAY. You can make a claim on every credit card you have had in the last 6 years.

    Reclaim Credit Card Charges NOW

  • Had a Loan - Sold PPI?

    PPI - PPI has been mis-sold alongside MILLIONS of loans, mortgages and credit cards.

    Got a Claim for £1000s?


    Find Out More Now

  • Have you got a Will?

    70% of people do not have a will (but keep meaning to get one)exposing their loved ones to financial harm.

    Only £149.95

    HouseFind Out More
  • Read Our FREE Law Guides

    We have guides on every legal subject we can think of. We are on your side, and maybe the law is too.

    Read More